Byredo Gypsy Water:
Byredo Gypsy Water is inspired by the romanticized vision of the gypsy lifestyle, filled with the freedom and oneness with nature, and is an ode to the beauty of discovery and the journey itself.
Its scent profile is a tantalizing blend, merging the earthy, woody elements of pine needle and sandalwood with the sparkling freshness of lemon, pepper, and juniper berries, ultimately evolving into a warm, comforting base of amber and vanilla. The end result? An addictive, unisex fragrance that draws you in with its mystique, making it a popular choice for fragrance connoisseurs.
Fragrance Notes:
Fragrance Description: Gypsy Water is an ode to the beauty of Romani culture, its unique customs, intimate beliefs and distinguished way of living. The scent wakens a dream of a colorful lifestyle made of innate nomadism. Woody notes of pine needle and sandalwood associated to intense amber and fresh citrus evoke the fever of gypsy nights spent in the forest.
from Fragrantica:
by Rosie Jane Lake:
Lake by Rosie Jane is inspired by the serene and lush beauty of Lake Tahoe during the fall. Designed to encapsulate the bohemian spirit, this perfume offers a journey into nature’s lap, whisking you away to a tranquil world with its harmonious blend of aromas.
Opening with the bright and zesty notes of bergamot and citrus, the perfume immediately awakens the senses, mirroring the refreshing nip in the Tahoe air. The scent embodies the clear, blue skies of the lake, inviting you to take a deep breath and bask in its invigorating freshness.
As the initial citrusy burst gives way, the heart of the fragrance emerges with an enchanting blend of neroli. Known for its slightly sweet, floral character with a hint of a metallic undertone, neroli provides a sense of calm and peace. It encapsulates the tranquil hush of Tahoe’s dense forests, casting a soothing spell that envelops you in its embrace.
As the perfume dries down, the base notes of warm vanilla and robust sandalwood come forward. The comforting aroma of vanilla, with its sweet, cozy resonance, evokes the comforting feeling of a warm blanket on a cool fall evening. In contrast, the sandalwood brings a rich, woody depth, mirroring the majestic pines surrounding Lake Tahoe. This expert interplay of notes leaves a lasting impression, much like the unforgettable sight of the lake at dusk.
With its intricate weave of fresh citrus, floral heart, and warm, woody base, By Rosie Jane Lake Perfume paints a vivid sensory picture, allowing the wearer to experience the allure of Lake Tahoe, regardless of their locale. Whether you’re a bohemian at heart or simply wish to carry a piece of nature’s tranquility with you, this fragrance is your bottled escape into the wild.
Fragrance Notes:
Fragrance Description: Lake is inspired by fall and spending time in hills of Lake Tahoe. It combines woody notes of pine and sandalwood with crisp, clean citrus notes of bergamot and lime, capturing the bohemian in all of us.
from Fragrantica:
Scent Summary – Gypsy Water vs. Lake Both Gypsy Water and Lake have very similar scent profiles.
The primary difference is the top notes, or opening of the perfumes. The opening of Gypsy Water is a bit more harsh, with notes of pepper and pine needles.
Although both have top notes of lemon and bergamot, the citrus opening is more prominent in Lake.
After the initial spray (about 15 minutes), the dry down of the 2 perfumes are nearly identical.
Byredo Gypsy Water:
Founded by Ben Gorham in 2006, Byredo has evolved into an internationally recognized luxury fragrance house. But did you know that the brand was born from a chance meeting between Gorham, a former professional basketball player, and perfumer Pierre Wulff?
Intrigued by Wulff’s perfume samples, Gorham embarked on a journey to explore the power of scent and memory. Gorham was inspired to create the brand after the loss of his father, which led him on a quest to explore the power of scent in evoking emotions and memories. The brand’s ethos – translating memories and emotions into products and experiences – is reflected in each of its unique fragrances.
In May 2022, Byredo was acquired by Puig, a large Spanish fashion and perfume company.
Byredo perfumes are known for their high-price tag and are sold at retailers like Saks 5th Avenue, Nordstrom, Neiman Marcus and Bloomingdales. There are dozens and dozens of different perfumes in the Byredo lineup.
by Rosie Jane Lake: By Rosie Jane, was founded in 2010 by Rosie Jane Johnston. A makeup artist by trade, Johnston turned to creating fragrances after becoming frustrated with the lack of straightforward, clean, and sustainable options on the market.
By Rosie Jane was born from this desire for simplicity and transparency. All of the brand’s products are crafted in small batches in Los Angeles, using recycled and recyclable packaging. Johnston’s mission is to make beauty simple, safe, and fun with a line of products that are as uncomplicated as they are effective.
Even though By Rosie Jane is a newer player in the fragrance world, it has quickly gained a dedicated following for its approachable, environmentally friendly products. Its fragrances, including Lake, are known for their clean, fresh scents that speak to the everyday woman.
By Rosie Jane perfume are sold at Sephora and are known for their affordability. There are 7 perfumes in the by Rosie Jane perfume lineup.
Brand Summary – Gypsy Water vs. Lake
Byredo and by Rosie Jane are two very different brands.
Byredo comes with a higher price tag, more perfume options and is available in more stores.
by Rosie Jane only has 7 perfumes in their line, comes with a more affordable price-point, and can be found at Sephora.
Byredo is owned by a larger company, while by Roise Jane is still owned by the original founder.
Byredo Gypsy Water: The Byredo Gypsy Water perfume bottle is a clear, cylindrical glass container. The bottle is crowned with a black, cylindrical cap, adding a contrast to the otherwise monochromatic palette. On the bottle is a white label, with the brand name ‘BYREDO’ in bold, uppercase letters, and the fragrance name ‘GYPSY WATER’ following suit in a larger font.
by Rosie Jane Lake: The by Rosie Jane Lake perfume bottle is a clear, cylindircal glass container. The bottle is crowned with a silver, cylindrical cap. The bottle doesn’t contain any lables, but rather has the brand and name of the perfume printed right on the bottle.
Bottle Summary – Gypsy Water vs. Lake Both Byredo and by Rosie Jane come in cylindrical glass bottles. By Rosie Jane is taller and skinnier and Byredo is shorter and wider. Byredo has a white label, while the by Rosie Jane bottle has the brand and perfume name etched right on.
Byredo Gypsy Water: Gypsy Water comes in multiple sizes:
1.7 oz (full-sized bottle) = $205
3.4 oz/ 100 mL (full-sized bottle) = $290
Gypsy Water also comes in a roll-on perfume oil for $78.
by Rosie Jane Lake: There is one full-size of by Rosie Jane perfumes.
1.7 oz (full-sized bottle) = $75
There is also a travel-size and roll-on perfume oil:
.35 oz travel spray = $28
.23 oz roll-on perfume oil = $45
Price Summary – Gypsy Water vs. Lake Gypsy Water is over double the price of Lake by Rosie Jane.
Byredo Gypsy Water:
There is controversy surrounding Byredo Gypsy Water. While Byredo’s Gypsy Water has enjoyed popularity for its unique scent profile, it hasn’t been without its share of controversy. The contention primarily stems from the use of the term “gypsy” in its name—a term often considered derogatory and insensitive towards the Romani people.
Historically, the term “gypsy” was used to describe the Romani ethnic group, a traditionally nomadic people with roots in Northern India. The word carries a burden of stereotypes, misconceptions, and negative connotations, often used to portray the Romani as dishonest, unreliable, or criminal. Over time, it has been recognized by many as a racial slur.
Byredo, by using the term “gypsy” in their fragrance, intended to capture the romance and freedom associated with a nomadic lifestyle, not to offend or stereotype an ethnic group. However, critics argue that this is a form of cultural appropriation, exploiting and romanticizing an often-marginalized group’s culture and history without proper respect or understanding. They assert that it perpetuates harmful stereotypes and misrepresents the reality of Romani life.
Many have called on Byredo to change the perfume’s name, highlighting the need for more culturally sensitive branding practices in the industry. This controversy underscores the ongoing conversation about cultural sensitivity, the importance of understanding the contexts and implications of the words we use, and the responsibility brands have in shaping and reflecting societal norms.
by Rosie Jane Lake: There is no controversy surrounding by Rosie Jane Lake perfume.
Controversy Summary – Gypsy Water vs. Lake There is controversy surrounding the name of Byredo’s Gypsy Water. There is no controversy surrounding by Rosie Jane’s Lake.
Byredo Gypsy Water: Byredo does not disclose details behind the ingredients used in their perfume. More on that here.
Byredo perfumes are not vegan or cruelty-free.
by Rosie Jane Lake: by Rosie Jane perfumes are made without questionable ingredients like:
by Rosie Jane perfumes meet the “Clean at Sephora” standards and are also vegan and cruelty-free.
Ingredients Summary – Gypsy Water vs. Lake by Rosie Jane’s Lake is a “clean” perfume, made without ingredients like parabens, phthalates and PFAS. Lake is also cruelty-free and vegan. Byredo Gypysy Water, on the other hand, is not cruelty-free or vegan. Byredo is also not transparent about their ingredients, thus we have to assume that their perfumes do have parabens/PFAS/phthalates/etc.
by Rosie Jane’s Lake is a great dupe for Byredo’s Gypsy Water. The initial spray is slightly different, but the dry down and how the perfume wears, smells identical. For the price difference and the clean ingredients, Lake by Rosie Jane is the clear choice.
Lemon-scented perfumes give you a zesty pep in your step and make every day feel like a sunny, fun-filled adventure! Here’s the best lemon perfumes!
If you’re looking to boost your teen’s confidence, check out these perfumes.